The following objectives will show how marketing and financial measures will be determined, as well as, Ann?s anticipated time frame for action.
Ann needs to develop some marketing savoir-faire. She is currently operating in a niche market that is developing into way of life (healthy living). The multisegment marketing strategy should instead be used. Although herbs and plants is a niche, she has selected more than one segment. For instance, one segment is the apple tree customers while another is kids lip balm. I think this strategy is best for Ann. Who she is selling to can be measured by their demographics.
Ann will use ROI to determine her net profit starting this year. Previously no records were kept. This would best be accomplished by using a database and excel to track customers and their buying habits. A scorecard based on her goals as stated in the goals section are as follows (note that Internet goals are what she will use once online):
Goals |
Possible Measures |
Increase conversion rates at Web site |
Orders/visitors |
5% ROI for each product in 2004 |
ROI |
Develop market share for online products |
Number of visitors Sales |
The time frames to make her business initiatives happen are well within reach. These initiatives are:
|
�� Quality control �� Increase number of plants sold
�� Increase amount of land that
can be planted |
A better look at the initiatives and their frame are:
Continue to produce the finest organic
plants to be used for medicinal purposes. Develop standards that go
beyond organic certification standards. �� Increase number of plants sold
�� Increase amount of land that
can be planted
|
ID |
Project |
Duration |
Start |
Finish |
Person |
Jan |
Feb |
Mar |
Apr |
May |
June |
July |
Aug |
Sept |
Oct |
Nov |
Dec |
1 |
Quality |
365 days |
Jan 1 |
Dec 31 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
2 |
Website |
60 days |
Jan 1 |
Mar 1 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 |
Presence |
120 days |
Jan 1 |
Apr 30 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
4 |
Tractor Job |
150 days |
June 1 |
Oct 29 |
Intern |
|
|
|
|
|
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
5 |
Fertilization |
30 days |
Nov 1 |
Nov 30 |
Intern |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- |
|
Ann wants to start this plan at the beginning of next year. Ann is a reasonable woman. She knows she is going to need help and money. Part of her plan is to seek out experts in website design and e-commerce at the end of this year so she can be ready.
Ann needs to find a way to handle her competition. The first obstacle will be for her to figure out what the difference is between local and Internet competition. Online she can?t afford to have her play nice attitude.
The first thing Ann should do is copy write her logo (as seen in the header of this page). She knows how she wants to be viewed as stated in her goals, but she needs to make sure she can cross the people skills she has now over to the web. Locally everyone knows who she is and thinks highly of her, but in the online world she has a strike against her. This strike is her previous web failure. Her previous customers can no longer e-mail her, or get to her site. They get a 404 error message if they try. This is a bad experience for most and one they will remember.
Ann, even though everyone plays nice, has a lot of competition. Examples are:
There is so much competition all she can do is offer a superior product and wait for the return customers, which she has plenty of. Once online the game changes. Even the threat of the economy is fixed because the web reaches regions where the money may not be tight.
In addition to the issues listed in the situation analysis, being online requires additional thought and insight.
Online she doesn?t have to worry so much about the overall economy because there is always an area with the financial means to buy. That market just has to be found.
In addition to the guidelines set
to be organic, online there are regulations too. Because she operates mostly
with plant material, she can not ship outside the
In addition to natural disasters that could happen on the farm, the computer poses potential problems too. Sometimes they naturally just don?t work.
Ann needs to find a very good service provider and someone who can handle the net traffic for her.
The following is a strategy for Ann based upon the analysis and the
SWOT.
Online, her target market changes. As stated in the analysis she speaks
to three different classes:
1.
Those who want to be
in on the new trend, fad
2.
Fellow Herbalists
3.
Browsers
The first class is pretty web savvy and so she targets them the same.
She uses nice baskets to get their attention and muted attractive colors.
The second class (unless a big organization) doesn?t really care for the
Internet and I know several of them who don?t even have a computer. For the
ones who are on-line, it will be very important to stress the practical uses of
the product. They are not into flash and glitter. For this reason it will be
important to have a separate link that says ?For fellow herbalists.? Here Ann
can talk to them using the plants scientific name and make them feel welcome.
The third group is an interesting group. Just like at the farmers
market, they just browsed in. The trick is to keep them. So they should be
marketed like the first group.
The first group of customers consist, in part, of the flashy type. They want to be fist and have the best. These are the high end customers. They aren?t looking for a deal, just a great looking product they can have in the kitchen. Ann usually sells this group custom baskets.
The second group of customers are Ann?s friends and fellow herbalists. These are the back to nature types. They want the lowest price going and won?t settle for second best. This crowd isn?t interested in the product aesthetics, just what it can do. They are kindly critical and are very careful not to take somebody else?s product.
Then we have the third group. I call them the browsers because they just happen by the farm or farmers market. They look around and buy something that seems like a good deal to them. They care how the product looks, though not as much as the first group, but require a moderate (fair) price.
The customers come from all over
the
All of these women are educated, yet form different classes. Most would consider the nature group to be of a lower class than the trend setters and followers, but they are actually quite well versed in the passion of their choice and genuinely believe� that the products are better for them and for the earth.
For the industry, sales are surging forward at a rapid pace and no
decline is in site. We are becoming a very health conscious country. This
statement is echoed by U.S. Department of Agriculture.
?Industry estimates put retail sales of organic products at $5.5 billion in
1998, up from $1 billion in 1990. Organic users? demographics: 40% are 36 to 55
years old with 25% likely to have a college degree. (Lamancusa, 2002).? This industry is growing has been
and will continue to grow by 24% a year (Colberg,
2000).
The following model is provided to assist in understanding where Ann is and wants to go:
Ann will sell merchandise only on her website. She won?t sell advertising because her ethics would only allow her to advertise certain companies. Those companies are also her competition.
She already participates in product
customization for the high end target market. But online this could be much
more sophisticated. She could have a fill your own basket discount structure,
as well as, a pre-organized basket selection.
Ann would be most profitable using the direct marketing approach. Ann
wouldn?t be able to sleep at night if she had an intermediary distributor
because of her high standards (she won?t even shop at Wal-Mart because she
believes they drive out small businesses). This method will also allow her to
keep her prices down.
Once Ann has her database completed she should participate in dynamic
pricing. This will be especially important to the browser segment that has made
a few purchases. This group in particular would like to receive benefits for a
high level of ordering. It will also enable her to keep her customers. I
believe it is the browsers that will make up the most of her sales (based on
80/20 rule) if this strategy is implemented.
Ann is best participating in personalized promotions that target each of her three customer profiles differently. The high end customers won?t be as interested in sales as they are in trendy new products and the browsers will tend to buy more if they get a bonus.
Another way to promote online could be to offer virtual herb walks or a question period for others in a chat room she is in.
Herb Plants - medicinal use |
Ann and Interns |
Heirloom Seeds - preservation of heirloom
varieties |
Ann and Interns |
Ann
is an herbalist with 10 years experience
Interns
come from all over and have various experiences and backgrounds
Ann has serious personnel issues. It is
very hard to attract an intern and then they only stay for a short time. Once
they see how small the town is and how hard the work is, they leave. Interns
and apprentices, however, are cheap if you can get them. Usually they get paid
$100 a week and free room and board is provided.
Ann is in good shape financially. She
owns her entire business and owes no one. She is very tight with her money. Her
biggest purchases were a green house and a tractor. This means she buys her
materials every year with cash on hand (hates credit).
Ann is trying to expand as demand for her
product is overwhelming her. She already has the land and equipment so just
needs the time.
Her greatest limitation is time. She works at four jobs in addition to running her business. If she is going to succeed, she has to concentrate on Oxbow Herbs & Heirlooms only.
Ann also has a very limited expertise in
the field of technology. She needs to take a computer class, but I believe she
should outsource the whole job. This is because she not only doesn?t have the
technical expertise, she doesn?t like it.
So, how is Ann going to accomplish all of� this?
Ann keeps total customer satisfaction as
her number one priority. Because of this she will perform the following steps:
1. Get the 404 page not found links on the
Internet to go away.
2. Start asking what customers want when
they come to the market or the farm.
Although a priority is to participate in
e-commerce, it is on the low end. She realizes she one of the 75% who failed
the first time due to lack of planning and knowledge. Also, she knows she
didn?t make it easy for a customer to buy from her:
1. Doesn?t accept credit cards
2. Site not interactive (no basket)
3. Had to print of an order from and mail it
to her
4. Site was boring - static
This also meant that her business didn?t
reap any rewards for having an on-line environment. She didn?t save on shipping
because she had to mail out brochures all the time.
So, if priority one is customer service
and the last priority is getting on the web, than the second priority is to
continue to have the highest quality standards, and the third priority is to
hire an expert to help her with site design and maintenance.
This schedule is taken from the analysis
section under time frame and the objectives section of the analysis. It is a
very aggressive schedule, but Ann believes she can do it.
ID |
Project |
Duration |
Start |
Finish |
Person |
Jan |
Feb |
Mar |
Apr |
May |
June |
July |
Aug |
Sept |
Oct |
Nov |
Dec |
1 |
Quality |
365 days |
Jan 1 |
Dec 31 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
2 |
Website |
60 days |
Jan 1 |
Mar 1 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 |
Presence |
120 days |
Jan 1 |
Apr 30 |
Ann |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
4 |
Tractor Job |
150 days |
June 1 |
Oct 29 |
Intern |
|
|
|
|
|
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
|
|
5 |
Fertilization |
30 days |
Nov 1 |
Nov 30 |
Intern |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- |
|
� To have 100 acres of farm planted by 2010
� Be one of the top 10 mail order companies for organic herbal plants by 2006.
�
Create a web site that uses e-commerence by 2005 to boost market share.
Most of these goals are quite tangible
and so easy to track. The only one I feel she needs sophisticated software for
is the market share goal. I would recommend a tracker be put on her site so she
can see exactly how many of her customers are buying or browsing.
There are many ways Ann can get feedback. Surveys of customers, asking, or just to see them smile (when in person of course) are all methods of feedback. This section also supports my decision to put a tracker on her web-site. If she sees someone logging on, but not buying, a survey can be sent out with a discount for their time.
Unclous Camps in Oxbow,
The Oxbow Lodge in Oxbow,
World Atlas for a map of
Lamancusa, Kathy, Organic Product Sales Grow, http://realtytimes.com/rtnews/rtapages/20020711_trendtalk.htm, Available online June 18, 2003, Reality Times.
Colberg, Sonya, Organic Farming Gains Momentum as Food Sales Draw Profits, http://www.pmac.net/momentum.html, Available online June 18, 2003, Knight-Ridder Tribune